Taylor was our server and she was amazing. Very attentive to our needs and wants. She makes a mean bloody Mary, BTW. I had a dozen raw oysters on the half shell and they were huge and served with plenty of "fixins". My girlfriend had the shrimp and oyster basket which came with 2 sides. She chose the hush puppies and thyme, garlic potatoes and she loved it! Well done to all the staff at Oyster Bay. We WILL be back.
R Anthony
-
January 18, 2026
Well the food was delicious,just don't know why it cost $72...with tip $80 for one order of crab legs and one order of Cajun pasta...waiting for manager to call me back... 🙄
Food & Truth
-
September 06, 2025
Cool spot. The rajun cajun and grouper fish sandwich were great! The spinach tasted frozen but everything else was great. I would recommend for a chill date night! Great service.
Stuart Farmer
-
July 17, 2025
Stopped in for a late lunch and wasn't disappointed. We had fried oyster & fish basket and a fried fish basket. Very flavorful and tasty. It was a slow time of day, but you can tell they have an entertaining atmosphere. Definitely coming back.
Phillip Minkoff
-
May 04, 2025
All in all, Oyster Bay delivered a top-notch dining experience. Whether you're a seafood lover or just looking for a great meal in a friendly setting, this place hits all the right notes. I’ll definitely be returning—and next time, I might try their oysters, which looked amazing at nearby tables.
Highly recommended!
Our Address
125 W Crogan St suite b, Lawrenceville, GA 30046, USA
Claim Listing : Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Taylor was our server and she was amazing. Very attentive to our needs and wants. She makes a mean bloody Mary, BTW. I had a dozen raw oysters on the half shell and they were huge and served with plenty of "fixins". My girlfriend had the shrimp and oyster basket which came with 2 sides. She chose the hush puppies and thyme, garlic potatoes and she loved it! Well done to all the staff at Oyster Bay. We WILL be back.
Well the food was delicious,just don't know why it cost $72...with tip $80 for one order of crab legs and one order of Cajun pasta...waiting for manager to call me back... 🙄
Cool spot. The rajun cajun and grouper fish sandwich were great! The spinach tasted frozen but everything else was great. I would recommend for a chill date night! Great service.
Stopped in for a late lunch and wasn't disappointed. We had fried oyster & fish basket and a fried fish basket. Very flavorful and tasty. It was a slow time of day, but you can tell they have an entertaining atmosphere. Definitely coming back.
All in all, Oyster Bay delivered a top-notch dining experience. Whether you're a seafood lover or just looking for a great meal in a friendly setting, this place hits all the right notes. I’ll definitely be returning—and next time, I might try their oysters, which looked amazing at nearby tables. Highly recommended!